Duino Elegies: A Bilingual Edition

ISBN: 0865475466
ISBN 13: 9780865475465
By: Rainer Maria Rilke Edward Snow

Check Price Now

Genres

Classics Currently Reading Favorites Favourites German German Literature Literature Poems Poetry To Read

Reader's Thoughts

أسيل

لا الطفولة ولا الآتي يصيران اقلوجود لا حدود لهيفيض في القلب

Garrett Peace

Actual score: 3.5. I'll place some blame on the translation for now, as I just grabbed whatever the library had, but I wasn't as in love with these as I thought I would be. The Eighth and Ninth Elegies are the most striking on first read and made reading all ten worth it (this is not to disparage the other eight elegies: they're quite good), but as a whole it lacked an emotional resonance that I'm looking for with poetry like this. Disappointing but definitely worth a read. I will be researching different translations for further (re)reading.

Xavier

I can't write it better than this editorial review. Read on."We have a marvelous, almost legendary, image of the circumstances in which the composition of this great poem began. Rilke was staying at a castle (Duino) on the sea near Trieste. One morning he walked out on the battlements and climbed down to where the rocks dropped sharply to the sea. From out of the wind, which was blowing with great force, Rilke seemed to hear a voice: Wer, wenn ich schriee, hörte mich denn aus der Engel Ordnungen? (If I cried out, who would hear me up there, among the angelic orders?). He wrote these words, the opening of the first Duino Elegy, in his notebook, then went inside to continue what was to be his major work and one of the literary masterpieces of the century."

matt

I thought Stephen Mitchell's translation was the best that could ever possibly exist. I was, happily, totally wrong. I picked this up at a friend's house by chance and was completely absorbed. The Chrichtons bring out a sort of conversational quality in the writing which I hadn't been aware even existed. Rilke's meditations are spectral, evanescent, secular and luminous. I didn't know there were other ways to appraoch the Elegies and now I see that there's a whole new world inside this text I was never quite aware of before. If you're already into Rilke, and even if you're not, do yourself a huge favor and dig in to the primal metaphysical mojo going on here. It could change your life.O, and the inclusion of three letters he wrote about the sequence are enough to make you stand up on the midnight subway and shout incomprehensibly about Time, God, Nothingness, Returns, and the inevitability of all parting. Yep. It's THAT good.

Alessandro

[Ma perché essere qui è molto, e perché pareche il tutto qui ha bisogno di noi, questosvanire che strano ci accade. A noi,i più svanenti. Una volta,ciascuno, solo una volta. Una volta, e non più.E noi anche una volta. Mai più. Ma questoesser stato una volta, seppure solo una volta:esser stato terreno, non sembrava revocabile.]Dalla Nona elegia

Ahmed Azimov

الشاعر الذي صب كلماته الموزونة في صميم وجوديّة هيدجار

Jesse

These poems blew my mind, kicked my ass and sent chills down my back. Never have poems so resonated with that dark secret place I keep hidden from view. But these poems threw back the curtain and shined with angelic vengeance upon my internal cowardice. And this, really, is what I want poems to do: let me know I am not alone and that others have felt as despondant and helpless (in a very mental and spiritual way) as I have. I almost didn't finish reading the poems because I felt my heart being stabbed (literally) and I couldn't take, what Henry James calls, the surprise of recognition. Only this was a brutal and beautiful surprise. One that changed the way I saw poetry and myself . This was some sort of poetical acid: sinister and illuminating, horrifying and unforgetable.

Sophie

Πουθενά, Αγαπημένη, δέν θα ύπάρχει Κόσμος, παρά έντός μας.Μέ μεταμόρφωση διαβαίνει ή ζωή μας, τό έξωτερικό μας πάντοτεφθίνει και λιγοστεύει.από τις πιο όμορφες ποιητικές συλλογές που διάβασα φέτος. Ενώ τα προηγούμενα έργα του Rilke, τα οποία διάβασα, δε μου άρεσαν ιδιαίτερα ή απλώς δε με ξετρέλαναν, οι ελεγείες του Ντουίνο με επηρέασαν ψυχικά.Η συλλογή αποτελείται από δέκα ελεγείες τις οποίες άρχισε να γράφει ο ποιητής όντας στον πύργο του Duino, κοντά στην Τεργέστη. Όταν συμπληρώθηκε, μέσα σε μία δεκαετία, η γραφή των Ελεγειών, ο ποιητής τις συγκέντρωσε κάτω απ' τον τίτλο Duineser, δηλαδή του Duino.Σίγουρα ένα έργο που αξίζει να διαβάσει ο καθένας.

Alison

I read these I think around the age of 23, when I had my first true existential crisis. I was reading anything and everything I could find that mentioned death, mortality, the pain of existence, etc. I moved from the world of art to the world of psychology, in a sense, and Rilke has always exemplified to me one who is at once artist, philosopher, psychologist, spiritualist. His work vibrates with both the ethereal beauty and searing pain of life. I should read this again.

D_

The emperor has no clothes? I love modernist poetry so I thought I would like Rilke. Maybe it was just a bad translation, but it seemed as if I was attending a boring lecture that was vaguely philosophical but not at all evocative or meaningful.It was very difficult even to get through because there seemed to be no continuity in the imagery or the narrative. While T.S. Eliot was creating paintings of the world and using them to ask questions about life, Rilke was rambling; similar themes, very different effects.

Trevor Pardon

two thoughts, related- 1. why do people quote the bible so much? 2. why isn't this the bible??????

Stephen

But still prefer Mitchell's

Milly

Rilke himself wrote that he didn't know what these meant. I very much enjoy poetry--am addicted to the rhythm and sound and feeling of words, often to my detriment as a fiction reader--but I thought this was horrendous. Perhaps I would have enjoyed them more in the original.... In English, at least, the words and rhythms were wrong, and the ideas didn't resonate (perhaps because the poet wasn't sure what the ideas were). When I finished reading I was left only with a sense of pretentious emptiness. I've read some of Rilke's other work, and enjoyed that, but the Duino Elegies were incredibly unsuccessful from my point of view. Very famous, I realize, but... some of the worst poetry I've ever read.

Gabriele

E l'abbraccio, per voi [amanti], è una promessaquasi d'eternità. Eppure, dopo lo sgomentodei primi sguardi, e lo struggersi alla finestrae la prima passeggiata fianco a fianco, una volta per il giardino,amanti, siete amanti ancora? quando vi sollevateper porvi alla bocca l'un l'altro -: bevanda a bevanda:o come stranamente bevendo sfuggite a quel bere.[II elegia](Rilke è talmente immenso che segue un filo tutto suo.)Ma se i morti infinitamente dovessero mai destare un simbolo in noi,vedi che forse indicherebbero i penduli amentidei nocciòli spogli, oppurela pioggia che cade su terra scura a primavera.E noi che pensiamo la felicitàcome un'ascesa, ne avremmo l'emozionequasi sconcertantedi quando cosa ch'è felice, cade.[X elegia](E comunque esistono talmente tante traduzioni, che al solito l'unica versione che meriterebbe di esser letta è l'originale.)

David Lentz

In "Duino Elegies" it seems as if Rilke is explaining the meaning of his life indirectly to God through divine messengers the presence of whom we can scarcely sense. The 10 elegies succeed in finding the world in a word, as William H. Gass advised was the objective of the most earnest poets. Rilke's greatness emanates from his fearlessness in taking on an epic macro-perspective. He is, after all, peering out into the universe and hearing the whispers of angels to inspire him:"Who, if I cried out, would hear me among the AngelicOrders? and what if one of them would suddenlytake me to his heart."Rilke in the First Elegy goes on to say that "Beauty is nothing else but the beginning of terror, which we are just able to bear and we are stunned by it because it so serenely disdains to destroy us."This is fairly bold, even daunting positioning for a poet and Rilke means to attack the big stuff. He is grand like Faust addressing Mephistopheles. Or Milton in "Paradise Lost." Or Dante in "Inferno."Rilke's poetry is rich and densely packed with meaning. His elegies are epic in his perspective of the universe but there is a relative brevity compared to epic poets who take on the universe in lengthy discourse.It is perhaps the height of optimism that Rilke believes he can directly confront the meaning of the universe from a castle near Trieste, where Joyce also wrote, on the Adriatic Sea under the auspices of a patron in Marie Von Thurn und Taxis-Hohenlohe over four months.But the muse does come speaking in the undertones of summoned angels and Rilke listens attuned to their whispers to build in the divine dialogue an opus magnus from the turrets and towers of the castle walls.In the Second Elegy he writes:"Each angel is terrifying. And, alas, even though I knowabout you, almost deadly birds of the soul, I still invoke you."Some truly intriguing questions are framed from Rilke's discourse among the angels:"Does then the cosmic spaceinto which we dissolve, taste of us? Do the Angelsreally hold only that which spring from them,or do they, at times, as if by oversight, enfold unto themselvesa hint of our being as well?"In the Fourth Elegy he invokes the images of puppetry as he sits before the stage:"An angel has to come, take part, and draw the puppets up high.Angel and puppet: at last there is a real play."In the Seventh Elegy we find that Rilke is taking on the Zeitgeist, the spirit of time:"Do not believe that destiny is more than a summing up of childhood...The Zeitgeist builds vast reservoirs of power for itself, shapelessas the tense urge that it extracts from all things.He no longer recognizes temples. We are secretly hoarding these extravagances of the heart."In the Eighth Elegy he speaks more of destiny:"That's what destiny is: to opposeand nothing but that, and forever to oppose...And we: spectators, always, everywhere,turned toward everything and never outward.It overfills us. We arrange it. It falls apart.We rearrange it and we, ourselves, fall apart."A favorite few lines emerges from this elegy by Rilke:"Who, then, has turned us around like this, that we,whatever we do, appear like someone aboutto depart? So much like the man on the final hillthat shows him his whole valley for one last time,who turns, and stops there, lingering-,this, then, is how we live, forever taking our leave."In the Ninth Elegy he has advice for us when we address the angels and God:"Praise the world to the Angel, not the unspeakable one, youcan't impress him with grand emotion: in the Universe,where he feels so intensely, you are only a beginner. So showhim simplicity, shaped from generation to generation,that is ours and lives near our hands and within our sight.Tell him things. He will stand amazed...Look, I live. On what? Neither childhood nor futuregrows less... A surfeit of beingwells up in my heart."The final elegy deals with a woman named Lament:"That some day, emerging from the grim vision,I might sing jubilation and praise to assenting Angels.That of the clear striking hammers of my heartno one would fail me from slack wavering orbroken strings. That my weeping face wouldmake me more radiant; that my trivial tears might flower...We were, she says, a great race once."I urge you to take on Rilke's "Duino Elegies" and to read it slowly and linger on every radiant word: this is the really good stuff.Are we all no less than Rilke in his castle by the sea seeking to make sense of the tumult of the universe in dialogue with our own angels?The translation by Leslie P. Gartner is inspiring.

Share your thoughts

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *