Thought and Reality

ISBN: 0199207275
ISBN 13: 9780199207275
By: Michael Dummett

Check Price Now


Calibre Share List Currently Reading Default Dummett Kindle Metaphysics Not Gonna Read Philosophy Reference To Read

About this book

The key question of metaphysics is: What does reality consist of? This work sets out Dummett's views about some of the deepest questions in philosophy. It puts forward his controversial view of reality as indeterminate: there may be no fact of the matter about whether an object does or does not have a given property.

Reader's Thoughts


For the first half of this book Dummet seems to be heading towards the same mistakes that Russell makes but by the end you realise that Dummet is a much more modern mathematician and says some interesting things about the indefiniteness of maths: and therefore our perception of reality, but I still can't help feeling that for an Oxford lecturer it's a bit strange that he has ignored his predecessors Strawson and Grice.The book also finishes with a rather tired old argument for god that once again leaves me feeling that the influence of Spinoza is far greater than is ever acknowledged.This brilliantly readable book has done exactly what I hoped in clarifying my own opinions on the subject of thought and reality.


Ontological empiricism is not stupid. Existence precedes essence. This just reminds me of Oliveira from Cortazars Hopscotch: essentially a long, didactic, explanation of how we can't be sure that things are actually how they are. Cartesian philosophy is the way to go. Sorry Dummet, metaphysics is pointless.

John Christmann

This book was a fantastic exposition of the Dummett's semantic theory, as well as a rather succinct critique of the truth-conditional theories of meaning that are still rather popular. Dummett explains, in detail, his reasons for rejecting the universal validity of the law of excluded middle; and by entailment, his rejection of classical logic in favor of his brand of intuitionistic logic. The last two chapters are interesting looks at Dummett's view on objective reality (reality as it is in itself), and God.

Share your thoughts

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *